Supreme Court: States Can Ban Guys in Women’s Sports. Alito on Birthright Citizenship Ruling: Big Mistake. Battle of One Titan: Justice Jackson Rebukes Thomas. Socialist Wins in Colorado. Kotkin: America Still Great. More

The Supreme Court’s final releases featured two historic rulings with epic significance.

In a win for women athletes, the Court upheld the right of states to ban male athletes from competing in women’s sports events. CBS reports:

The Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled states can prohibit transgender athletes from competing on girls’ and women’s sports teams, a decision that delivers the latest setback for transgender rights.

In two of the most closely watched cases of its term, the Supreme Court upheld laws from West Virginia and Idaho that restrict transgender athletes’ participation in school sports. The cases are known as West Virginia v. B.P.J. and Little v. Hecox.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh authored the opinion for the majority, writing that under Title IX — the landmark law that promotes equal opportunity in sports — and the Constitution’s Equal Protection Clause, schools can base eligibility for women and girls’ sports teams on biological sex.

“Consistent with Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause, we hold that the States may maintain women’s and girls’ sports for biological females. They may determine eligibility for women’s and girls’ sports based on biological sex,” Kavanaugh wrote. “The Constitution and Title IX do not require an overhaul of women’s and girls’ sports throughout America.”

The three liberal Justices dissented. Sonia Sotomayor even read her dissent from the bench, which CBS took as “a signal of strong disagreement with the majority’s opinion.” The Manhattan Institute’s Ilya Shapiro, on the other hand, writes that the Court “stood up for girls in sports,” calling the ruling “a victory for fairness, reality, and the girls whom Title IX was meant to protect.” A Wall Street Journal editorial said the Court has “struck a blow for equal rights for women, federalism and common sense.” 

“Court Finally Gave Us the Protection We Need” is the headline on Paula Scanlan’s piece in The Free Press:

When Lia Thomas, a biological male, joined Penn’s women’s swim team, my coaches told me to accept it. The Supreme Court’s ruling on transgender athletes vindicated me.

Outkick’s Jackson Thompson reflected on the “years of sacrifice” leading up to the ruling. Praised in Thompson’s story is Riley Gaines, who in a separate story hails the ruling as an important victory but says the battle isn’t over (and specifically is calling out Simone Biles). Just to Be Clear: Justice Clarence Thomas tore into transgenderism as “a lie” in his concurrence and went further than his fellow Justices:

“Men and boys with gender dysphoria are not women or girls, even if they believe that they are. Sex is an immutable ‘biological’ characteristic,” Thomas wrote in his brief, two-page solo concurrence.

The Court’s ruling on birthright citizenship knocked many conservatives for a loop and is a setback for President Trump’s efforts to end illegal immigration:

The Supreme Court has ruled that babies born in the US have a constitutional right to citizenship, rejecting Donald Trump’s bid to end the 150-year-old policy.

In a 6-3 decision, Chief Justice John Roberts ruled that children born in the US “to parents unlawfully or temporarily present” are “citizens at birth” under the 14th amendment.

Justice Amy Coney Barrett, undoubtedly making herself even less popular among conservatives, sided with Roberts and the three liberal justices, making a 5-3 majority. Justice Alito’s dissent was blistering:

“In my judgment, the Court has made a mistake that will seriously affect the country’s future,” Alito continued. 

Justice Thomas wrote in his dissent that the ruling cheapens citizenship:

“I am not sure that today’s opinion will stand the test of time,” Thomas, the longest-serving conservative currently on the bench, wrote in a 91-page dissent to the ruling upholding the 14th Amendment right. “The Citizenship Clause ‘added greatly to the dignity and glory of American citizenship.’ Today’s opinion devalues that citizenship.”

Predictability Award: Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson “admonished” Justice Thomas—his dissent is racist, she said.

An editorial in the Washington Post called the ruling “judicial overreach” because it should have been decided on narrower grounds. Mollie Hemingway said on Fox that Chief Justice Roberts’ majority opinion is a “devastatingly bad decision for the future of the country” and compared it to Roe v. Wade and the Dred Scott decision, both of which were reversed in the fullness of time. In the meantime, conservatives may resort to patchwork corrections, made more difficult by the broadness of the ruling.

Oh, Say Can You See: Vice President Vance told Laura Ingraham that he can see “a big silver lining” in the “preposterous” ruling.

The Mamdani effect struck again yesterday in Colorado. Socialist Melat Kiros, 29, defeated 15-term incumbent Rep. Diana DeGe in the leftist insurgency:

Ms. Kiros, who has questioned Israel’s right to exist and called the Oct 7 massacre “inevitable”, appeared to be riding an anti-establishment wave, which commentators have called the “Mamdani effect” after Zohran Mamdani, New York’s socialist mayor.

The Gen-Z socialist, meanwhile, is already bossing House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries. 

Colorado’s Democratic Senator John Hickenlooper managed to defeat progressive challenger Julie Gonzales. Phil Weiser scored a win for Governor over Senator Michael Bennett:

Weiser cast himself as the “fighter” against President Trump, pointing to more than 65 lawsuits his office filed against the administration.

But guess who bobbited up: Colorado Rep. Lauren Boebert won the GOP primary, despite President Trump’s having called for a challenger.

A feature of the socialist surge is hostility to the state of Israel and Jews. Rich Lowry has a good piece on New York Mayor, the youthful progenitor of the socialist surge, and hizzoner’s lack of candor when it comes to his reasons for opposing Israel:

Mamdani makes it sound as though Israel is a theocracy, and so he has to withhold his support until such time as it meets his exacting standards for state neutrality in religious matters and freedom of conscience.

When is the last time, though, that you heard Mamdani or his movement, the Democratic Socialists of America, inveighing with great moral passion against Saudi Arabia?

This Mamdani line of argument is built on a falsehood about Israel and is transparently an exercise in bad faith and double standards.

“The American College of Surgeons Remains Committed to Ideology” is a City Journal headline. They invited Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson to deliver an important lecture as a way to underscore their support of DEI. Jackson knows about DEI, having been selected for a Supreme Court seat because she is a black woman.

Would you want a surgeon whose surgical skills were comparable to Justice Jackson’s legal astuteness to operate on you? Read in City Journal about the ACS’s alienation of medical professionals who advocate merit.

President Trump today makes his debut flight in his brand-spanking-new Air Force One,  a gift of the Qatari government. I think we have good cause to be queasy about the president’s accepting a gift of such magnitude from the Qataris, who just happen to be key in our negotiations with Iran. I guess I wish he had not unveiled the new plane in the lead-up to July 4. But that’s sort of a copout.

A good way to get in the mood for the Fourth is to read Joel Kopkin’s “The Enduring Promise of America.” He begins with an inspiring quote from John Dos Passos, and then writes:

America is, above all, a nation of ambition played out across a vast continental canvas. At times this makes us appear rude or short-sighted, but it is preferable to following Europe’s green-tinged anti-growth agenda amid ever-louder calls to expand the welfare state. The continent that gave birth to America is increasingly becoming a delightful destination for North American, Asian and Arab tourists. It is considerably less appealing, however, for working- and middle-class Europeans as their industries continue to decline, even in Germany.

For all its faults, America remains a restless country where people strive, often unsuccessfully, in their ‘pursuit of happiness’. …This restlessness tends to make inequality worse, but also makes us overall much richer. The animal spirits have not been entirely suppressed. Meanwhile, a more ‘civilised’ Europe has fallen behind in productivity, economic growth, investment and wealth per capita. Great Britain, the motherland of self-government and industrial innovation, has fallen so far behind that it would now be the poorest of our 50 states.