Come Together to Inspire, Interact, Influence, and Impact.

x
Notifications
Log Out? Are you sure you want to log out?
Log Out
IWN Staff
May 30, 2023 - 2 minutes
facebook linkedin twitter telegram telegram

In 60 Seconds: H.R. 4 And Federal Pre-Clearance

*PDF Download: In 60 Seconds – Pre-Clearance

H.R. 4 requires certain states and local jurisdictions with “history of intentional voting discrimination” to obtain federal approval to make any changes to voting or election laws.

This proposal unconstitutionally threatens certain state’s abilities to dictate how they will hold elections, thereby taking the power away from voters.

Here’s the issue of Federal Pre-Clearance in 60 seconds:

What You Need To Know

The Voting Right Act:

  • prohibits election policies that deny or abridge the right to vote on account of race or color (Section 2); and
  • requires certain jurisdictions with a history of intentional voting discrimination to seek federal approval (“pre-clearance”) of any election-related changes (Section 5).

Shelby Cty. v. Holder:

  • held that Congress may not rely on 40-year-old data to justify requiring local jurisdictions to seek federal approval of changes to election-related rules.

H.R. 4:

  • establishes new criteria for determining which jurisdictions are required to pre-clear all election changes for the next ten years; and
  • requires every state and local jurisdiction in the entire country to seek federal approval before adopting certain practices, such as strong voter ID requirements.

Problems with H.R. 4

It’s an unconstitutional federal takeover

  • Pre-clearance is only constitutional if used as a temporary remedy for intentional discrimination.
  • The original pre-clearance formula was carefully calibrated to cover southern jurisdictions that used tests purposely to deny ballots to black citizens.
  • H.R. 4 widens the pre-clearance net to cover any and every jurisdiction that wants to strengthen voter ID rules or alter procedures for printing and distributing multilingual materials.

H.R. 4 is disconnected from reality

  • In 1965, intentional voting discrimination was frequent and widespread. Today, it is rare. And yet, H.R. 4 broadens and intensifies federal pre-clearnce rules.
  • Changing a polling location or failing to provide ballots in every possible language is not the same as deliberately preventing black citizens from voting.
  • Pre-clearance was supposed to be temporary. Today, the permanent prohibitions on voting discrimination provide ample remedies.

Addressing Misperceptions

IWN Staff
Back to Resource Center

More from IWN Staff

State Legislature: Grassroots Trainings A Basic Overview: The Importance Of State Legislatures

There is no excerpt because this is a protected post.

IWN Staff May 15, 2025
State Legislature: Grassroots Trainings Basics of a State Legislature: How It Works And How Bills Become Law

There is no excerpt because this is a protected post.

IWN Staff May 15, 2025
State Legislature: Grassroots Trainings Terminology: Legislative Terms You Should Know To Be Effective

There is no excerpt because this is a protected post.

IWN Staff May 15, 2025
State Legislature: Grassroots Trainings Engagement: How To Make A Difference In Your State Legislature

There is no excerpt because this is a protected post.

IWN Staff May 15, 2025
Resource Center Leading Lady | Sami Keddington, IWN Chapter Leader

Leading Ladies, an Independent Women’s Network initiative, showcases and honors women who…

IWN Staff May 12, 2025

Related Posts by IWN

How To Talk About: Education Freedom

Education freedom policies allow education funding to follow students to the option…

IWN Staff January 27, 2025
How to Talk About: Education Freedom

EDUCATION FREEDOM *PDF Download Funds students, not systems. Unfortunately, school districts and…

IWN Staff January 27, 2025
In 60 Seconds: Education Freedom

*In 60 Seconds: Education Freedom What is Education Freedom? Education freedom funds…

IWN Staff January 27, 2025
How to Talk About: TEACHERS UNIONS

Five Key Points About Teachers Unions *PDF Download Unions seek power. Unions…

IWN Staff September 30, 2024
In 60 Seconds: Why Crime Statistics Can Be Misleading

Crime statistics delivered to the public don’t always align with the reality…

Paula Fitzsimmons August 8, 2024