Come Together to Inspire, Interact, Influence, and Impact.

x
Notifications
Log Out? Are you sure you want to log out?
Log Out
IWN Staff
May 30, 2023 - 2 minutes
facebook linkedin twitter telegram telegram

In 60 Seconds: Judicial Philosophy

*PDF Download: In 60 Seconds – Judicial Philosophy

Progressives want the Supreme Court to decide cases based on modern notions of fairness and social justice, rather than on the law as written. Because progressives view the Court as a super-legislature, rather than as a neutral arbiter of law, they seek nominees to the Court whom they believe are willing to legislate certain outcomes from the bench.

The president should nominate and the Senate should confirm only those candidates who possess a sound judicial philosophy.

Here’s the issue of judicial philosophy in 60 seconds:

What’s at Stake

Progressives want the Supreme Court to decide cases based on modern notions of fairness and social justice, rather than on the law as written. Because progressives view the Court as a super-legislature, rather than as a neutral arbiter of law, they seek nominees to the Court whom they believe are willing to legislate certain outcomes from the bench.

It is not the job of the Court to set public policy or to create new rights and remedies. Those jobs belong to the political branches of government, which are accountable to the people.

Nor is it the job of the Court to rubber-stamp popular laws that conflict with the Constitution. An unelected justice who is unwilling to enforce the limits of our governing charter puts all of our freedoms at risk.

It is, therefore, critically important that any nominee to the Supreme Court understand the proper role of the judiciary in our democracy.

Qualifications for a Supreme Court Justice

Supreme Court nominees should, of course, possess strong academic and legal credentials. But resumes are only part of the equation. From a diverse pool of many qualified candidates, the president should nominate and the Senate should confirm only those candidates who possess a sound judicial philosophy.

Nominees to the Supreme Court must demonstrate a commitment to:

  • enforcing the Constitution as written and
  • applying statutes passed by Congress consistent with their original public meaning

Even when doing so leads to outcomes with which they personally disagree.

A justice who fails to anchor her decisions to constitutional or statutory text is legally adrift, guided only by politics and her own personal morals and worldview.

Addressing Misperceptions

IWN Staff
Back to Resource Center

More from IWN Staff

Network reACTS Network reACTS: Patrice Onwuka Breaks Down New Jersey’s Attack on Independent Contractors

Julie Gunlock, Director of Independent Women’s Network, and Patrice Onwuka, Director of…

IWN Staff July 7, 2025
Network reACTS Network reACTS: Federal Investigation Launched into Fairfax County Public Schools

Neeraja Deshpande, Policy Analyst at Independent Women’s Forum, joins Stephanie Lundquist-Arora, IWN…

IWN Staff July 2, 2025
Network reACTS Network reACTS: What Trump’s Tax Cuts Mean for You – A Conversation with Patrice Onwuka and Cori Huston

Patrice Onwuka, Director of IWF’s Center for Economic Opportunity, joins IWN Leader…

IWN Staff June 30, 2025
Network reACTS Network reACTS: SCOTUS, Child Protection, and the Medical Backlash – A Conversation with Nan Hayworth and Beth Parlato

Julie Gunlock hosts a powerful conversation with Nan Hayworth and Beth Parlato…

IWN Staff June 27, 2025
Network reACTS Network reACTS: Bronwyn Sims Reacts to Simone Biles and Riley Gaines Tweet Clash

IWN National Chapter Director, Christy Narsi, sits down with IWN Southern New…

IWN Staff June 13, 2025

Related Posts by IWN

How To Talk About: Education Freedom

Education freedom policies allow education funding to follow students to the option…

IWN Staff January 27, 2025
How to Talk About: Education Freedom

EDUCATION FREEDOM *PDF Download Funds students, not systems. Unfortunately, school districts and…

IWN Staff January 27, 2025
In 60 Seconds: Education Freedom

*In 60 Seconds: Education Freedom What is Education Freedom? Education freedom funds…

IWN Staff January 27, 2025
How to Talk About: TEACHERS UNIONS

Five Key Points About Teachers Unions *PDF Download Unions seek power. Unions…

IWN Staff September 30, 2024
In 60 Seconds: Why Crime Statistics Can Be Misleading

Crime statistics delivered to the public don’t always align with the reality…

Paula Fitzsimmons August 8, 2024