Come Together to Inspire, Interact, Influence, and Impact.

x
Notifications
Log Out? Are you sure you want to log out?
Log Out

Good News: Trilateral Summit Has Few Achievements. ‘Bonfire of the Show Boaters.’ Ron Johnson Speaks Truth about Social Security. State Rep’s Wife is Illegal Alien. Twilight of the Never Trumpers. More

After wall-to-wall coverage of the “historic” trilateral meeting in Shenzhen, China, CBS reports that President Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin appear to achieve little.

And that’s the good news, according to Dana Perino yesterday on The Five. The three didn’t make any bad deals. They talked about nuclear weapons and agreed to talk more about nuclear weapons.

An editorial in The Wall Street Journal appears to take a position not dissimilar to Perino’s:

The best one can say about President Trump’s meeting with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin is that it could have been worse. Mr. Trump appears to have conceded nothing on Ukraine or Taiwan, and the group statement is diplomatic pabulum. But allow a word on Thursday’s joint “declaration toward peace.”

The U.S., Russia and China, we are told, “will conduct a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons.”

But hold on. The biggest nuclear risk on the planet today is Mr. Putin, who has repeatedly and ostentatiously threatened to use battlefield nuclear weapons in Ukraine.

The MSM media has gone nuts about what they see as three dictators meeting. Perino made another point: Putin and Xi were meeting with a man who had “lost everything” in the recent midterms; his party suffered an epic rebuke. That doesn’t happen to dictators. Ms. Must is betting that the Left won’t give up on the Trump will never leave meme even after the U.S. inaugurates a new President on Jan. 20.

The Left had yet another hissy fit when—practicing diplomacy—President Trump called Vladimir Putin “my friend.” Well, maybe President Trump could give the Vlad-is-my-friend thing a rest. “President Trump needs to get it through his head: Putin isn’t his ‘friend’” Issac Schorr’s New York Post headline suggests:

President Trump needs better friends.

And a photo-op with Putin during which the “f-word” made yet another suspect appearance.

“Who is he?” asked the president with a point and mirthful laugh during the latter. “He’s my friend.”

He really isn’t.

After the trilateral meeting broke up, President Trump dialed into a meeting of the “coalition of the willing” in Berlin. He seems to have made quite an impression. The U.K. Telegraph reports:

Donald Trump told European leaders to withhold funding from Ukraine in an angry phone call after his summit with Vladimir Putin.

It is difficult for Republicans to discern the silver lining in their midterm wipeout, but Wall Street Journal columnist Kimberley Strassel finds a glimmer. She calls it “the bonfire of the show boaters: possibly the best opinion piece of the day“:

It’s been three years since House Republicans have experienced that normal known as majority sentiment. On Oct. 3, 2023, a small band of grandstanding rebels realized the extraordinary power they had to dictate the actions of their caucus. Eight Republicans used a motion to thwart the remaining 213, linking arms with Democrats to remove Kevin McCarthy as speaker. (And then to raise money off their show of “principle.”) This set the model for the GOP House ever since—a yearslong spectacle of camera-chasers using arcane procedures to force-feed their demands.

Sayonara, egotists—only the cameras will miss you. 

Let’s see—yesterday’s tech disaster was Visa and Mastercard data released by hackers. An editorial in The Wall Street Journal suggests that the “tech panic” is coming at a time of low government credibility:

The Trump Administration sent mixed messages from the start. Or consider Vice President JD Vance the same day. “I’ve had a lot of my friends reach out and say, ‘Should we be preparing to build a bunker or to stock up on food and water?’ And my answer to that is no,” Mr. Vance said. “We do not see some crisis coming down. But you have to be prepared for everything.” Ok then. No need to build a bunker, but check the freeze-dried emergency rations.

Well, we can’t say Senator Ron Johnson’s warning about Social Security was anything but direct and clear. “Ron Johnson Tells the Social Security Truth” is the headline over a WSJ editorial:

Mr. Johnson is in his final days as Senate Budget Chairman, and this week he released a report showing how Social Security’s finances are unsustainable. No one else wants to say it, but the math is inexorable.

While average life expectancy has increased to 79.1 from 63.6 in 1940, the Social Security retirement age has risen only to 67 from 65 during this time. In 1940 there were 159.4 workers for every Social Security beneficiary. Last year the ratio was 2.6 to one.

This unsustainable system is what Mr. Johnson was referring to when he compared Social Security to a “Ponzi scheme.” That was a political mistake because it gave Democrats an opening to say he wants to destroy Social Security when he really wants to start a debate about the problem and possible solutions.

Democrats pretend the only way to shore up Social Security is to remove the $184,500 cap on the 12.4% Social Security payroll tax. Ohio GOP Sen. Bernie Moreno has joined hands with Democrat Elizabeth Warren on the idea.

Mr. Johnson suggests repealing the 2032 cliff that forces the 22% Social Security benefit cut, which would take pressure off Republicans to agree to a massive tax hike that harms workers and the larger economy.

Democrats don’t want to hear any of this.

“Wife of Somali Daycare State Rep. Is an Illegal Alien.” What were the odds?” Minnesota-based Powerline asks. Pretty high is the answer.

The Biggest Cultural Event of Our Era Happens Today. Are You Playing? It’s Grand Theft Auto VI. For those of us who missed GTA 1-IV, Liel Leibovits of TFP explains:

The game lets you tune in, drop out, and never look back—and that is what’s so scary about it.

“Masked protesters chanted ‘Charlie Kirk deserved to die’ outside TPUSA event at University of Washington.” I don’t understand why Kirk has become such a hate object for the Left. I mean, all the father of two did was engage in debate. Perhaps in the age of “Elissa Slotkin’s Coming Inquisition,” being willing to engage in debate is enough to earn undying enmity.

Rich Lowry writes that the Senate filibuster hangs by a thread and that its loss will shatter the Founder’s system. The same can be said of the Electoral College.

Twilight of the Never Trumpers. National Review finds the movement is now cringe. Sarah Longwell, editor of the Bulwark, the magazine of the Never Trumpers, confessed over the weekend:

“You may know us, we’re the Never Trumpers. At least we were ten years ago. Now we’re just kind of libs just like the rest of you.”

Meanwhile, Jonah Goldberg, stalwart of the Bulwark, sends around an email to tell us what we are all absolutely perched on the edges of our chairs to know: “Why I Squabbled with The Bulwark.”

Nvidia Overshadows Trilateral Meeting. Speaker Jeffries. Rove: Dems Should Remember Why They Won. GOP Should Ponder Their Future. Extreme Poverty Thing of the Past in India. Why? More

First, the hug.

Chinese President Xi Jinping broke protocol to greet President Trump on the tarmac, where he administered the hug.

Fox Digital calls the trilateral meeting featuring President Trump, Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin “unprecedented,” adding that breakthroughs remain elusive:

President Donald Trump joined the leaders of China and Russia Thursday for an unprecedented three-way summit, marking a historic moment in global diplomacy as the three powers discussed nuclear arms reductions, the war in Ukraine and global security without announcing a major breakthrough.

The unprecedented three-way meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin underscored the leaders’ commitment to continued diplomacy, with Trump emphasizing the importance of maintaining dialogue among rival nuclear powers.

The Wall Street Journal notes that the meeting takes place at a time of “shifts in world order”:

The first-ever gathering of the American, Chinese and Russian leaders was a further sign of the end of a unipolar world order dominated by the U.S.—and suggested that what might replace it is a more uncertain, and unsettled, reality.

The trilateral comes on the heels of the scandal involving Jensen Huang, disgraced Nvidia CEO, victim of an alleged Chinese spy espionage operation. Nvidia manufactures chips that China would love to get its hands on (as in steal). The Free Press says that the trilateral meeting takes place “in the midst of a scandal”:

With a high-stakes summit in China on the horizon and Nvidia embroiled in controversy, Washington faces mounting questions about its relationship with Beijing.

Indeed, the Huang scandal hangs over the trilateral gathering and has reinvigorated Washington’s China hawks:

Claims that Nvidia customers funneled billions of dollars of sophisticated chips to Chinese AI companies have collided in recent days with a string of technological breakdowns—from a nationwide ground stop for airlines to bank-account glitches and money-transfer delays. …

On Monday, before President Trump boarded Air Force One to meet with China’s Xi Jinping this week in Shenzhen for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meetings, he defended Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, who has resisted restrictions that might anger China—despite opposition from Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and other officials.

Many businesses that realize a relationship with China, or an intermediary, could hurt them politically are paying more attention to those new policies and the threats from the incoming Democratic-run Congress than Trump’s words, business advisers said.

China is our most important economic rival. A Wall Street Journal op-ed by Hernando de Soto conveys the distressing news that China is winning in Latin America.

Back home, Rep. Hakeem Jeffries was easily elected Speaker of the House. It wasn’t the donnybrook many anticipated; in fact, it was such a strong showing that Jeffries and his allies could afford to “laugh off” the dissenters, but several progressives voted against Jeffries:

Seven of the 11 no votes came from progressive Democrats: Reps. Darializa Avila Chevalier, Adam Hamawy, Frederick Haynes, Melat Kiros, Donavan McKinney, Chris Rabb and Claire Valdez. The group said in a statement that “there is still work to be done to ensure that the direction our party takes this coming Congress reflects what our constituents are demanding of leadership. Those conversations are ongoing. As such, our vote in caucus today was no.”

Senate Republicans hoped to pass a budget before January 3, when the Democrats will control both houses, but the odds look slim. Kimberley Strassel writes that the odds of passing a reconciliation bill to do that are low. Democrats are “torn” over floating new taxes to support their multi-trillion-dollar agenda. To that point, USA Today’s Nicole Russell writes that the GOP failed to lower the cost of living and asks if Democrats will even try. Democrats, as Karl Rove notes, were giddy when they arrived in Washington last week for freshman orientation.

Rove advises Democrats to remember why they won and not get carried away with radical policies and endless investigations:

This election wasn’t a seismic shift toward Democrats but a rejection of Donald Trump.

According to the Fox News Voter Analysis, a survey of more than 70,000 Americans who cast ballots, only 36% approved of Mr. Trump’s handling of his job, while 63% disapproved. While Republicans and Democrats largely stuck with their own parties, independents broke for Democrats 59% to 31%. That’s how they swept the suburbs and cut into the GOP’s rural margins.

Another complication for Democrats is that much of the party’s energy comes from its democratic-socialist wing. That’s a loser with the broader electorate. Fox found only 18% of voters described themselves as democratic socialists, and voters were more than twice as likely to say they’d rather not support a democratic socialist candidate (30%) than say they would (13%).

The same survey found that 56% of voters had a favorable view of capitalism and 32% an unfavorable one. Only 34% viewed socialism favorably while 53% see it unfavorably.

Just as Mr. Trump misunderstood his 2024 election victory, Democrats risk misjudging their 2026 victory. If they do, 2027 will be an interesting year.

As far as I can tell, the Republican strategy for building for the future is to wait until the Democrats overreach. In “The GOP Ponders Its Purpose,” Barton Swaim ponders what he thinks they should do:

The GOP’s decadelong experiment with Mr. Multitudes has brought triumphs and debacles, but the political effect is a party that forgot how to present big ideas to the public. Republican pols, with a few noble exceptions, talk about ideas and policies only when lampooning beliefs supposedly held by the “establishment” in some bygone era.

Read various accounts of the Contract with America and the 1994 midterm elections. The idea that today’s Republican Party could attempt anything so ambitious, substantive and free of buzzword-laced demagoguery will draw a laugh from GOP oldsters.

Confabs about the future of the Republican Party and conservatism will proliferate in Washington over the next month or two, but the argument that most needs resolution is more basic than any set of policies. Secretary of State Marco Rubio takes a side in this argument each time he delivers a speech or makes remarks premised on the belief that America and its bourgeois capitalist economy are fundamentally good and our enemies abroad fundamentally are not.

Gas prices are falling—just in time to not help the GOP avoid a wipeout.

When well-intentioned people decide to “help” the Third World, they usually mean foreign aid and socialist policies (regulations, etc.), but a piece in today’s Wall Street Journal (“Extreme Poverty Is a Thing of the Past in India“) illustrates how counterproductive that is:

While the world is focused on China’s rise, another economic transformation in Asia has largely gone unnoticed. India, the world’s most populous nation, has all but eliminated extreme poverty.

India could have escaped the poverty trap sooner had it embraced wiser policies. In their book, “A Sixth of Humanity” (2025), political scientist Devesh Kapur and economist Arvind Subramanian document the folly of the state-led model of development India embraced after independence in 1947. Messrs. Kapur and Subramanian point out that for the first three decades (1950-80) the poverty rate barely budged. In 1980 about 57% of India’s population—or about 390 million people—lived below the poverty line.

The inflection point came in 1991, when, faced with a balance-of-payments crisis, India ended industrial licensing, slashed tariffs and embraced foreign investment. As growth soared, the economy generated more well-paid jobs and gave the government the resources to assist the poor. Unlike many developing countries, India has generally maintained a conservative monetary policy to keep inflation in check.

“Congrats on Your Anthropic Shares” is a Wall Street Journal editorial that explains (pace Bernie Sanders and AOC) why the company’s IPO benefits taxpayers and workers far and wide:

Progressives fume that the IPO will increase wealth inequality since Anthropic executives and employees will be able to cash out shares. This will mint many new billionaires and millionaires. What’s wrong with that? They are being rewarded for the risk they took by founding and joining Anthropic. They could have gone to work at more established companies, or a sinecure like the federal government.

Government pension funds also stand to benefit. At least 18 state and local government pensions hold Anthropic shares through private investments in funds that have disclosed stakes, according to the Equable Institute.

But the biggest manifest threat is government.

New York Post: AI Apocalypse. End Is Nigh. Veep’s Friends: Should We Build Bunkers? Peltola Flips Alaska. Sad Autopen Writes Book, Gets Panned. NY To Be Like Paris—But Not in a Good Way. More

The big story this morning is AI Apocalypse—it’s big enough to grab the cover of the New York Post: A guy with a flowing white beard holds aloft a sign that reads, “The End Is AI.”

“Fear grips nation over tech crashes and hacks,” the headline continues, but “Don’t Panic Experts Say.”

Well, now, we know about experts. Vice President JD Vance’s friends (who?) are worried. “‘A lot of my friends have reached out asking if they should prepare to build a bunker or stock up on food and water,’ the vice president told Fox News host Laura Ingraham on Monday night. ‘We don’t see a crisis coming down,’ Vance added, ‘but you have to be prepared for everything.’’’ That’s not exactly a firm “no.” Previous Apocalypse reports have been consistently wrong.

On a more down-to-earth level, The Wall Street Journal addresses the possible causes of the recent string of outages and finds a mundane answer:

As sophisticated AI tools find vulnerabilities in critical software, the patches to fix them are coming in fast … and messy.

In “Is America’s Infrastructure Under Attack?” at The Free Press, “H.R. McMaster, Tyler Cowen, Michael Shermer, and other experts weigh in on a week of outages, rising cyber threats, and the possibility of foreign interference.”

The latest AI incidents to fuel this concern are yesterday’s outage at the highly classified network that the U.S. ‌National Security Agency uses for its ‌internal communications and the outages at banks and Apple. The banks and Schwab outages are scary. The Drudge Report devotes its top headlines this morning to promoting fear. My favorite fear headline promoted by the Drudge Report: “What Is the White House Hiding?” For all the technological and scientific advances of our age, we seem quite credulous.

The great Joel Kotkin explores “Why the fall of Jensen Huang is shaking the world” at Spiked Online. “AI’s concentration in a tiny coterie of nerds and capitalists poses a threat to our prosperity and security,” Kotkin argues. Here are key points Kotkin makes:

Huang’s fall, which has compounded a stock-market rout that could exceed $1 trillion, also shows how the AI industry has become both far too concentrated in a few hands and far too important to the wider economy. Seen as the creator of a future tech utopia, AI is becoming an industry more akin to the pre-war Japanese zaibatsu – a set of conglomerates empowered by money and political connections. Nvidia itself has large investments in several other chip firms, as well as companies building data centres.”

Perhaps the closest analogue to the current situation is the dotcom crash of the early 2000s, which devastated both Wall Street and California – although this time the effects may be far more pervasive. Nvidia grew its Bay Area workforce by about 1,000 in 2025, the biggest increase among the region’s 20 largest tech employers, according to Joint Venture Silicon Valley’s 2026 Silicon Valley Index. Overall, however, those 20 companies collectively cut their Bay Area workforce by about 13,400, or five per cent.

The pain will be felt elsewhere, too. Building data centres has become very unpopular, as the midterm elections showed. They are unpopular not only in deep-blue states but also across the country, including among Republicans. As energy analyst Robert Bryce points out, rejections of data-centre projects have risen from nine in 2024 to 48 last year and 70 in the first quarter of this year. Many good blue-collar jobs tied to these centres may be lost in the current anti-AI wave.

Even Europe, and particularly Britain, is vulnerable to an AI crash. After all, AI has been among the few forces lifting Britain out of its pervasive doldrums. With its considerable chip-design expertise and financial power, the country has benefited from AI. Now an AI crash could plunge the UK economy into an even deeper slump.

The Huang humiliation further worsens the already awful image of the tech oligarchs, who have become the favourite whipping boys of the rising socialist left. The other leading figures in the AI industry are people you would certainly not want in control of your life. Anthropic’s Dario Amodei and his merry band are fond of joking about their agents destroying humanity, perhaps thinking that it does not include them. 

What happens next is somewhat predictable. Democrats will demand hearings, and Huang, Lutnick, and perhaps Sacks, who is still openly defending Huang, may face public humiliation. They will rightly be questioned about how the supposedly nationalist MAGA administration allowed the sale of advanced chips to America’s biggest rival while failing to cooperate with Singapore’s efforts to investigate the alleged Chinese asset, Alice Huang.

The Democratic Left in particular feels empowered. Bernie Sanders, Ro Khanna and Elizabeth Warren will demand control over these companies, and even nationalisation.

Can You Guess the Word of 2026? “Every November, editors of the Cambridge Dictionary anoint a word of the year that captures the moment. The latest selection says a lot,” is how New York Times writers introduce the word (or words):

Last month, Dartmouth College held a conference celebrating the anniversary of a workshop conducted in 1956, in which a group of scientists and mathematicians coined the term “artificial intelligence.” They were declaring a new field of study, one engaged with the question of whether human cognition and intellect could be replicated by a machine.

Decades later we find ourselves swirling around in the vortex of the existentially destabilizing answer, forced to make a positive case for people. “AI at 70: What Must Remain Human?” was the title of the Dartmouth convening, out of which it was determined that “human flourishing, human judgment and human will” were all worth preserving.

In more normal news, Mary Peltola won the Alaska Senate seat running against two Dan Sullivans. This flip gives the Democrats a 55-44 edge in the Senate.

President Trump is traveling this week, and an editorial in The Wall Street Journal characterizes his journey as “Trump Meets with the Anti-U.S. Axis.” From the editorial:

President Trump meets with smiling foes Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping this week in Shenzhen, and the summit raises questions about the world Mr. Trump hopes to build in his final years in office. It’s a sign of Mr. Trump’s mercurial foreign policy that the parley is creating more anxiety among allies than adversaries.

The President says a focus of the trilateral meeting will be nuclear weapons, though the menu could also include Ukraine, Iran and trade. “We’re going to talk about denuclearization,” the President told reporters. “Tough subject, because it’s very hard for any of us to say we’ll get rid of our nukes, right?”

The President has long had a genuine hatred of the bomb, and his record on the issue is strong.

Manifesting this concern, a Washington Post headline demands that Congress must stop Trump from giving this non-democracy a nuclear bomb; The Wapo suggests that a nuclear Saudi Arabia could pose an Iran-like threat.

Where Are The Think Tanks, Now that We ….? Has anybody noticed that there has been remarkably little thought about what went wrong building a GOP future (beyond New Gingrich’s excellent Republicans need history lesson about their party if they want to move on from defeat)? 

New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s disbanding of the NYPD unit trained to handle riots was an important story yesterday. “Mamdani’s New York Will Soon Resemble Paris” is a Free Expression headline: But New York won’t resemble Paris in a good way. Edward Conlon argues:

Whether the issue is Gaza, Trump or high prices, protesters don’t typically take to the streets in search of ‘dialogue.’

And James Freeman of the same esteemed newspaper issues “Another Cautionary Tale for MamdaniMarts“:

As more than a century of experiments in socialism have demonstrated, supermarkets without market discipline tend to disappoint consumers. This week brings yet another cautionary tale as New York City prepares to launch city-owned grocery stores starting next year.

With apologies to Omar Khayyam, who did not marry his sister: The moving autopen writes, and having writ, moves on. Yes, Joe Biden’s eagerly anticipated memoir is out. It’s entitled “Promise Me, America,” and its Amazon rating is 70 (the lower the better, which means that whoever okayed a big advance is getting chewed out today). Zoe Strimpel of the U.K. Telegraph found it “deeply arrogant – and slightly bizarre.” Strimpel writes:

Promise Me, America, which covers Biden’s four-year presidency and its brutal end, is arrogant and defensive. It reads like a testimony written in prison by a zealot who refuses to accept the jury’s verdict.

“‘Promise Me, America’ Review: For Being Wrong, a Gift” is the headline on Wall Street Journal’s Barton Swaim’s review. Swaim writes:

The defining fact of Mr. Biden’s career is that he didn’t know when to run for president. In 1987 he bowed out after nonsensically trying to pass off a British politician’s words as his own. He ran again in 2007 but got nowhere against Barack Obama. In 2015, Vice President Biden chose not to run. In his memoir he attributes that decision to the stress occasioned by the death of his son Beau, but numerous reports at the time indicated that Mr. Obama and others in his administration urged Mr. Biden to step aside for Hillary Clinton. Hindsight strongly suggests that Mr. Biden, with his well-honed working-class persona and stumbling charm, stood a better chance of beating Donald Trump than the haughty and angular Mrs. Clinton did.

Only in his third attempt, in 2020, did Mr. Biden succeed, the luckiest and unluckiest choice of his long career.

“All excuses” is Unherd’s verdict.

Old Men Forget. Biden forgot to mention Britain when listing allies of the United States.

Sure Are a Lot of Coinkydinks Lately. When Air Force One Seems Too Small: Nvidia Rivals Bessent & Lutnick Flying Together. Disbanding NYPD Riot Unit. Newt: GOP Forgot Abe. More

A spate of coincidences?

“From grounded flights to frozen bank accounts, why does it seem like everything is breaking at once?” USA TODAY asks. A Boston NBC affiliate describes our recent spate of tech disruptions—from airplanes being grounded to bank accounts being unavailable—“the perfect storm.”

Yesterday’s tech disruption consisted of service outages at major U.S. banks:

Customers at JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America, U.S. Bank and other major financial institutions reported service outages on Monday, according to Downdetector.com.  

Other banks that saw a spike in customer complaints about difficulty accessing their accounts included Capital One, Truist and Wells Fargo, while users also reported problems with the digital payments app Zelle, according to the outage tracker.

However, Downdetector showed that service was back to normal at the banks and Zelle early Tuesday.

Fox’s Brit Hume is always sane and measured, so I was somewhat surprised by his comments on Special Report last night. Hume speculated that, as seeming coincidences pile up, we must entertain the notion that it is “mischief from a foreign or domestic adversary.” Along these lines, but potentially even worse, U.S. intelligence has picked up “very specific” Iranian plans for a “dirty bomb” in Washington, D.C.

Meanwhile, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy’s ask for funds to modernize our air traffic system meets with a big fat no from the Washington Post:

The optimal amount of taxpayer funding for operating and modernizing air traffic control is $0.

Before taxpayers write another check, lawmakers should ask why they are financing this service at all. New Zealand became the first country to spin off ATC in 1987. Today, 96 countries receive air traffic services from self-funded providers separate from government transportation ministries, according to the Reason Foundation. Canada, Britain and Italy use private or partially private operators. Many others use government-owned corporations.

More sanguine, former Speaker Newt Gingrich offers Congress different advice: “Replace, Don’t Repair, the Air-Traffic Control System.”

Don’t you hate it when you must sit by someone who’s not congenial on a long airplane trip?

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, who have clashed over Nvidia chips and China, are flying together on Air Force One with President Trump. The president is heading to several international meetings. Bessent and Lutnick can make their cases to the president on the looong flights. The Washington Post highlights the rift:

Bessent has publicly criticized the Commerce Department for not taking a tougher approach to China-related chip exports, saying other officials pushed to issue restrictions but “Commerce has the pen.”

The debate has also drawn scrutiny from lawmakers, who have pressed Lutnick to explain why his department did not move more aggressively to restrict chip exports, and whether Commerce’s enforcement decisions have left critical technology within Beijing’s reach.

The dispute between Lutnick and Bessenthad taken a dramatic turn with a new federal rule that sought to close a loophole that allowed Chinese companies to remotely access advanced Nvidia chips. While Chinese firms are normally barred from directly purchasing the valuable technology, they had previously been able to access them by renting computing power from data centers located outside China.

More on the administration’s internal rift over China and Nvidia.

The president, incidentally, is taking the Qatari-gifted Air Force One. The pièce de résistance of the president’s jaunt is the unprecedented trilateral meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping, which is being closely watched by U.S. allies. Are you thinking what I’m thinking? There is good and very bad news in “Why This Week’s Meeting of World Leaders Won’t Be Yalta 2.0” in The Wall Street Journal. Yaroslav Trofimov writes:

Russian officials are already comparing this week’s three-way summit with the U.S. and China to the historic 1945 Yalta Conference where the victors of World War II gathered to decide the fate of Europe. 

But the meeting of President Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping, planned for Thursday in the Chinese city of Shenzhen, is more likely to reveal the limits of the great powers to impose a new international order as the Pax Americana comes to an end.

Unlike the statesmen in Yalta, the leaders of the U.S., China and Russia, however, won’t be gathering as the winners in a global conflict that they had fought shoulder to shoulder. 

Two leaders are bogged down in wars that, in various ways, have weakened their global standing and show no sign of abating. In America’s case, the unpopular conflict with Iran also helped trigger a wave of Democratic victories in the midterms likely to curtail Trump’s domestic power…..

“It’s really a summit of the three weaknesses. Russia is economically broken, and militarily experiencing a disaster. Trump is now a lame duck with a difficult situation at home. And China is facing grave domestic economic difficulties,” said Italian Sen. Carlo Calenda. “All three are in a much more precarious position than it seems.”

Despite all the propaganda, Russian officials understand that the true importance of the Shenzhen summit lies more in its symbolism than the substance.

Will President Trump raise the most pressing question of former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, apparent victim of a Chinese honeypot espionage ploy that cost Huang his position? Here’s one take:

When President Trump sits down with Xi Jinping in Shenzhen on Thursday, the most dramatic national-security story in the U.S.-China relationship will be the one neither leader raises…. As an internal policy split within his administration over export controls burst into the open, Trump struck a conciliatory tone. “We’re heading to China, and I don’t think you want to insult China just before you get there,” he told reporters Monday.

Time magazine explores what both Trump and Putin hope to get out of the meeting.

With Huang out at Nvidia, we’re learning more about the culture of put-downs and kowtowing to Nvidia’s “royal family” inside the giant chip maker. Kudos to whoever wrote the magnificent headline (just the headline, mind you) on Maureen Dowd’s column last week: “Goodbye, Mr. Chips.”

Who needs to defund when you can just disband?

The New York Times headline has it that New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s disbanding of the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, which, among other things, handles riots, has provoked “praise, anger and spin.” Praise comes from “criminal justice activists,” which is a euphemism, but not from police organizations. Former law enforcement official William Bratton, who formed the SRG, writes today in the New York Post that Mamdani’s action will turn out to be a painful lesson for New York:

New York City can reorganize its Police Department, as Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced Monday — but it can’t reorganize away the threats that require a fast, coordinated response.

As the commissioner who created the 600-officer Strategic Response Group and the 500-officer Counterterrorism Critical Response Command, I know why we built them — and what they were meant to do.

SRG was designed to give the NYPD a trained citywide force that could respond to major incidents, help control crime in troubled areas, support large public events and manage demonstrations that turn into serious disorder.

It was also trained to respond to the kind of active-shooter attack that can overwhelm ordinary patrol resources.

New York has learned, often painfully, that crowd management demands preparation, discipline and restraint.

The SRG is also the unit that keeps crazies away from synagogues.

Ms. Must has overindulged in international affairs this morning. Closer to home, don’t miss “Voters Asked for Affordability—Washington Can’t Borrow Its Way There,” at Real Clear Politics; Newt Gingrich’s eloquent piece on what the GOP forgot (it’s something Lincoln said) that contributed to their midterm wipeout, and “Too Big to Bail,” by Nicole Gelinas in City Journal, about our impending financial catastrophe (required reading for Rep. Ro Khanna, who somehow thinks it would be a good idea for the government to send all citizens $1,700 to make up for the Iran conflict).

Free-Speech Watch. Both Dominic Green and Meghan Gurdon invoke the travails of Ms. Must’s nomination for Greatest Living Novelist Michel Houellebecq in pieces on our imperiled right to freedom of speech. 

Ms. Must can’t believe she forgot to celebrate the 250th birthday of the great New York Post yesterday!

Couldn’t live without it.

Glad I’m Not Flying Monday. Devine: Fire Lutnick. Is Van Hollen For Real? School Choice Under Threat. Big Marco Rising. Anthropic Nerds Hiring Matchmakers. More

After Friday’s grounding of all flights in the U.S., America’s airports are “gradually returning to normal.” Airlines are putting out upbeat statements, but with caveats: customers “may still experience delays or cancellations.”

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, who made the decision to ground all flights in the U.S., blames Congress and previous administrations for the air traffic disruption. The Washington Post seemed surprised that Duffy didn’t apologize:

“It happened on my watch,” Duffy said of the 4½-hour halt to flights across the country on Friday, which led to the cancellation of 12,000 commercial and private flights that day and thousands of others over the weekend.

“But we have to be clear: I am moving at an incredible speed that no one has done at the FAA or in decades,” Duffy continued in an interview with “Meet the Press” on NBC. “I can’t apologize for what was passed off to us.”

Yet he reiterated his calls for Congress to allocate more than $50 billion in emergency funding for needed upgrades to the U.S. air traffic control system that he saidhad been ignored for years.

“I can’t blame Republicans or Democrats, because it’s all of them,” he said. “It goes back 20, 25, 30 years of a lack of investment.”

Duffy warned of future outages if the air traffic system is not updated. The Secretary singled out defense contractor L3Harris as possibly sharing some of the blame. An FAA router in Arkansas appears to have triggered the nationwide grounding. An editorial in the Wall Street Journal (“The FAA Is a Classic Government Failure”) predicts more disruptions if the system is not reformed:

Long-term upgrades are hostage to annual Congressional appropriations. Government unions and lawmakers obstruct investments and reforms to improve efficiency. United Airlines CEO Scott Kirby last week said he thought privatizing air-traffic control could get upgrades “done in two to three years.” No less than Al Gore championed reform in the 1990s.

Yet private jet operators and unions blocked GOP legislation during the first Trump Administration to follow Canada’s example and turn the system over to a nonprofit to run. (See Marc Scribner’s persuasive analysis nearby.) Republicans appear to have given up on even pushing the idea. Expect flying headaches to continue as long as government won’t give up political control of the skies, despite its manifest and growing failures.

A Wall Street op-ed bluntly argues that we “need to spin off air traffic control. A self-regulating agency will never be modern and safe.”

Looks like Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick could be in deep trouble over the Nvidia scandal. Miranda Devine, the influential New York Post columnist, yesterday urged President Trump to fire “the embarrassing Howard Lutnick” over Nvidia concerns. Meanwhile, there is a campaign to bring back disgraced former Nvidia CEO Jenson Huang. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent (we seem knee-deep in Secretaries this morning) is raising questions about Nvidia’s stakes. Axios notes:

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent on Sunday questioned whether Nvidia’s earnings might have been inflated by inappropriate sales to China and urged the company to hire an outsider as CEO.

Why it matters: Nvidia is central to the AI economy, which has been key to U.S. economic growth.

Why didn’t Nvidia take steps to deal with the Jensen Huang matter earlier? “Nvidia Shows the Limits of Corporate Boards” is the headline of a Wall Street Journal op-ed:

Set aside Mr. Huang’s personal conduct. The case lays bare an Achilles’ heel that Beijing often exploits: the limited perspective of corporate boards. …

Yet few directors of major American companies have experience assessing political risk and the nature of regimes like communist China’s. They don’t learn it at business school or law school. Many directors have never worked or lived in a hostile environment like China’s, where there is no rule of law, property rights, independent boards or expectation of privacy. If they think about geopolitical risk, it’s often through the lens of regulatory risk, such as compliance with the 1977 U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act….

The [Huang] episode should also serve as a wake-up call to every American company doing business in places like China, and to the directors in their boardroom, too.

Axios has a story on how the Nvidia fiasco affects our personal finances.

The Nvidia scandal fuels the anti-AI movement. Rikki Schlott writes that this “neo-Luddite” movement forgets the “wonders and life-changing improvements” AI has brought us. Andy Kessler examines the benefits AI brings to medicine in “Doctors Have a New Assistant” in The Wall Street Journal.

Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland made the rounds of Sunday shows to talk about his announced challenge to Senator Schumer to be Senate Majority Leader. An editorial in The Wall Street Journal suggests that Van Hollen isn’t likely to depose Schumer:

It’s best understood as a warning from the party’s ascendant left wing: Toe the line on our agenda, or you won’t have a career after 2028. …

All of this ignores that Mr. Schumer has already moved sharply to the left in recent years. 

Eli Lake of The Free Press takes the Van Hollen challenge more seriously and interprets it as showing that the Democratic Party is changing:

If  you want to know just how far left the Democrats have traveled since their triumph in the midterms just two weeks ago, pay close attention to what happens to Senator Chuck Schumer.

Democratic power in five of the six states that spend the most money on voucher programs means that school choice is under threat. In “First They Came for the Children,” a Wall Street editorial explains:

That didn’t take long. Fresh off their statehouse victories around the country, Democrats are promising to use their power to eviscerate school voucher and education scholarship programs….

Democrats oppose the program because it offers parents a choice other than a failing neighborhood public school. Sarah Eckhardt, a Democratic state senator who was elected comptroller, voted against the ESAs and will oversee the program. She has called for more accountability and transparency, which is union code for using regulation to strangle the program….

Some 1.5 million children participate in private-school choice programs nationwide. Roughly half are in states that elected Democratic governors and could be affected by moves to restrict the programs. It’s a shame that children could become collateral damage to the voter rebuke of President Trump.

Townhall’s irrepressible Kurt Schlichter says the battle for the GOP presidential nomination for 2028 is wide open—but it won’t be JD Vance. Meanwhile, David Catron of the American Spectator writes that Ron DeSantis has won his 2028 shot by offering “a lesson in conservative governance that Washington Republicans would do well to learn.” Sasha Stone hails “Rubio Rising.” And Big Marco himself warned at a Federalist Society gathering about the International Criminal Court and the “weaponization of international law.”

Remember how we were told that “our democracy” was under attack? Surprise, surprise! “Perhaps the Rumors of Democracy’s Demise Were Premature,” a New York Times headline now tells us. You already know what saved it. Bill Glahn of Powerline comments.

Nerds want to be beautiful, too. “Meet the Matchmakers Getting Anthropic Employees Laid” in The Free Press is this morning’s most heartwarming story:

Soon-to-be-rich AI staffers are getting hair transplants, paying women to teach them intimacy, and spending $500,000 on elite matchmakers.

Just be careful about gorgeous Chinese ladies who might be overly interested in what you do at work all day.

Columnist Predicts ‘Brutal Huangover.’ Official: Van Hollen Challenges Schumer. Strassel: Jim Jordan is Mr. Right. Lefty War on Gig. DC Shooting. And More

The shock resignation of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang sent stocks in the chip giant dramatically downward.

New York Post financial writer Charles Gasparino is brutal—and not only to Jensen Huang, whose romantic liaison with an alleged Chinese spy triggered the whole mess:

Nvidia’s board finally woke up on Thursday morning – and the brutal “Huangover” is likely to last for a while.

If you feel sorry for these clowns for their dyspepsia, you shouldn’t. Yes they are clowns. This whole sordid mess goes beyond their wayward CEO and his sex life, and it was one of their own making. 

Recall: The chipmaker’s directors had spent the previous week insisting that there was nothing to see here – all business as usual, really – as the headlines multiplied about its CEO Jensen Huang’s affair with an alleged Chinese spy.

It’s spent the past year sidestepping questions about Huang’s wonky business dealings with the woman, the questionable firm she repped and how oddly this company pushed to sell its most advanced, national security sensitive chips to China, a foreign adversary. 

Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick is fighting for his job amid the repercussions. The New York Times notes that Lutnick could be in trouble because he hasn’t been tough enough with Nvidia:

There is broad agreement among most senior Trump administration officials that the United States should more aggressively tighten controls on Nvidia’s advanced chips to keep China from using them to catch up in the race to dominate artificial intelligence.

Then there is Howard Lutnick, who runs the Commerce Department.

“The Fallout from the Fall of Jensen Huang” is the headline of a Wall Street editorial, which argues that export controls can be instituted but that care must be taken not to harm American AI:

Jensen Huang’s resignation Thursday as the rock-star CEO of Nvidia was necessary following reports that he had affairs with a suspected Chinese spy and a subordinate. But it also does regrettable harm to the company and America’s AI industry, and maybe that was China’s plan. …

All of this is fair game, but the tragedy would be compounded if politicians use the episode to destroy Nvidia or damage the tech industry. Progressives point to Mr. Huang’s mistakes as evidence of corrupt tech “oligarchs.” Yet his self-combustion is a corrective to their claim that billionaires and CEOs can break rules with impunity….

Mr. Trump said he doesn’t plan to raise the Huang honey trap with Xi Jinping when they meet next week. This would resemble Joe Biden’s mistake of downplaying the Chinese spy balloon caught flying over the U.S. It would encourage Beijing to think it can target U.S. businesses and executives with impunity.

Mr. Xi may make great trade promises at the summit to get Mr. Trump to ease export controls on Nvidia’s most advanced chips. Don’t fall for this honey trap, Mr. President.

“Before His Ouster, Jensen Huang Belittled the Executive Replacing Him.” She is acting CEO Colette Kress, who questioned some of Huang’s dealmaking. President Trump urged Huang to fight for his job, but when he didn’t, Trump quickly switched to former Apple head Tim Cook, whom he touted in a Truth Social post.

It’s Friday the 13th, and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer must be in the appropriate mood. Lefty darling Senator Chris Van Hollen from Maryland has announced that he will challenge Schumer for the Senate Majority Leader job. Axios observes:

Van Hollen’s bid gives grassroots activists nearly three weeks to pressure Senate Democrats before they cast secret ballots in the Dec. 1 leadership election.

The attempt to oust Schumer (D-N.Y.) underscores that deep divisions are plaguing the Democratic Party despite its overwhelming midterm success.

Right Man for the Right Job. That’s what the Wall Street Journal’s Kimberley Strassel suggests is the case with Rep. Jim Jordan, newly elected as House Minority Leader (“Jim Jordan’s MIGA Moment“):

Mr. Jordan is a wrestler, both literally and figuratively. Yet the headlines ignore what more he has become during nearly 20 years in Congress. The Jordan fighting spirit remains, and it will matter in a GOP Washington under a Democratic assault. But it’s Mr. Jordan’s principles and relationships—and his credibility—that offer the GOP its best shot at coming back from a midterm humiliation….

What Mr. Jordan has going for him is his conservative credibility—try casting a “pugilistic” “bomb thrower” as a RINO. The question is how aggressively he uses his selling skills to convince his crew to tackle the issues Americans want tackled—healthcare, spending, government reform, welfare. That, and how well he can use his trusted relationship with Mr. Trump to waylay bad ideas and carve out space for his conference to forge a brighter path.

The election of Mr. Jordan at least raises the possibility of a twist on the mantra: MIGA. Make Ideas Great Again. It’s overdue.

“Democrats Will Certainly Overreach.” Matthew Continetti argues the Democrats “are making the usual mistake of confusing their big win with an endorsement of their agenda.” Continetti writes:

House Minority Whip Katherine Clark (D., Mass.) visited the liberal Center for American Progress Action Fund on Nov. 5 to discuss the blue tsunami. She called the midterm election a “peaceful popular uprising” over the Iran war, deportations and corruption. Then she went further. Democratic victories weren’t only a rebuke of President Trump, Ms. Clark said. “We were elected to transform a system that has been failing people for decades.”

Whoa, Nelly. The “t”-word—transformation—is invariably used by politicians about to overread their mandates. …

If voters were looking for major change last week, it was in President Trump’s conduct….

Hence Democrats have an opportunity to maintain and even grow their majorities in the next election. First, they must understand that their victory was broad, but their mandate narrow. Voters want them to check Mr. Trump and reduce inflation. Go too far, and it’s back to the minority before you can say “transform.”

DC Shooting. One person was killed and five injured in a shooting in Washington’s gentrified Logan Circle neighborhood. The shooter was a doctor, Matt Lambert, whose motive was furor over mold in his ritzy, million-dollar apartment. It was a bizarre attack that began in a gym and took the life of the manager of Lambert’s building:

Less than 10 minutes before the first calls about the gunfire came in, according to the Associated Press, Lambert appeared to post “My manifesto is an engineering report” on an X account named “OfMiceandMold” with screenshots from that report.

Additional details from the Washington Post and Axios.

“The Left’s War on Gig.” The Left wages war on the gig economy through regulations and mandates that end up hurting the very people progressives purportedly want to help:

A 20-cent delivery tax, or marginally higher food prices after a minimum-wage hike, may hardly register with a D.C. attorney ordering lunch at his K Street office or a Wall Street financier expensing a catered work banquet. But it matters to a retired janitor in Anacostia or the Bron x who can no longer drive and relies on grocery delivery. In Minnesota and Colorado—two blue states that enacted gig-delivery taxes in recent years—about a third of voters reported being less likely to order food delivery because of the new fees.

Progressives show little sign of backing down from the War on Gig.

But perhaps the most vocal anti-gig advocate is New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. As a candidate, Mamdani pledged a crackdown on gig platforms. Once in office, he turned the city’s Department of Consumer and Worker Protection into an aggressive gig-economy enforcer.

“Who’s Afraid of Books for Boys?” Emma Camp writes at Free Expression about debate on the internet over whether publishers need to provide more books written specifically for boys:

These arguments betray a frustratingly obvious double standard: If a book is enjoyed by mostly boys, that means that the book is actively harmful to the girls who are required to read it. But if a book is preferred by girls, the fact that boys don’t like it is a sign of their latent sexism….

Deciding to see men and women as individuals, rather than representatives of homogeneous, competing forces, allows us to remember that gender equality is gained not through revenge but by furthering the equal dignity of all human beings. Men’s and women’s destinies are tied up in each other’s welfare. If we want to make the world better, we have to do it together. And that might involve publishing a few more books for boys.

Two for the Road. Discover the benefits of colonialism (there were many—this is not a joke) in “Malawi hails British Empire as ‘liberators’ who saved Africans from slavery.” “Michel Houellebecq must not be silenced” is about yet another attempt to prosecute the great French novelist for daring to criticize Islam:

Even if Michel Houellebecq is acquitted, champions of free speech will have little to celebrate. A society whose most celebrated writer is constantly defending himself from Islamic grievances – whether by lawyers or armed police – has already lost a crucial battle.