Come Together to Inspire, Interact, Influence, and Impact.

x
Notifications
Log Out? Are you sure you want to log out?
Log Out

Glad I’m Not Flying Monday. Devine: Fire Lutnick. Is Van Hollen For Real? School Choice Under Threat. Big Marco Rising. Anthropic Nerds Hiring Matchmakers. More

After Friday’s grounding of all flights in the U.S., America’s airports are “gradually returning to normal.” Airlines are putting out upbeat statements, but with caveats: customers “may still experience delays or cancellations.”

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, who made the decision to ground all flights in the U.S., blames Congress and previous administrations for the air traffic disruption. The Washington Post seemed surprised that Duffy didn’t apologize:

“It happened on my watch,” Duffy said of the 4½-hour halt to flights across the country on Friday, which led to the cancellation of 12,000 commercial and private flights that day and thousands of others over the weekend.

“But we have to be clear: I am moving at an incredible speed that no one has done at the FAA or in decades,” Duffy continued in an interview with “Meet the Press” on NBC. “I can’t apologize for what was passed off to us.”

Yet he reiterated his calls for Congress to allocate more than $50 billion in emergency funding for needed upgrades to the U.S. air traffic control system that he saidhad been ignored for years.

“I can’t blame Republicans or Democrats, because it’s all of them,” he said. “It goes back 20, 25, 30 years of a lack of investment.”

Duffy warned of future outages if the air traffic system is not updated. The Secretary singled out defense contractor L3Harris as possibly sharing some of the blame. An FAA router in Arkansas appears to have triggered the nationwide grounding. An editorial in the Wall Street Journal (“The FAA Is a Classic Government Failure”) predicts more disruptions if the system is not reformed:

Long-term upgrades are hostage to annual Congressional appropriations. Government unions and lawmakers obstruct investments and reforms to improve efficiency. United Airlines CEO Scott Kirby last week said he thought privatizing air-traffic control could get upgrades “done in two to three years.” No less than Al Gore championed reform in the 1990s.

Yet private jet operators and unions blocked GOP legislation during the first Trump Administration to follow Canada’s example and turn the system over to a nonprofit to run. (See Marc Scribner’s persuasive analysis nearby.) Republicans appear to have given up on even pushing the idea. Expect flying headaches to continue as long as government won’t give up political control of the skies, despite its manifest and growing failures.

A Wall Street op-ed bluntly argues that we “need to spin off air traffic control. A self-regulating agency will never be modern and safe.”

Looks like Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick could be in deep trouble over the Nvidia scandal. Miranda Devine, the influential New York Post columnist, yesterday urged President Trump to fire “the embarrassing Howard Lutnick” over Nvidia concerns. Meanwhile, there is a campaign to bring back disgraced former Nvidia CEO Jenson Huang. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent (we seem knee-deep in Secretaries this morning) is raising questions about Nvidia’s stakes. Axios notes:

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent on Sunday questioned whether Nvidia’s earnings might have been inflated by inappropriate sales to China and urged the company to hire an outsider as CEO.

Why it matters: Nvidia is central to the AI economy, which has been key to U.S. economic growth.

Why didn’t Nvidia take steps to deal with the Jensen Huang matter earlier? “Nvidia Shows the Limits of Corporate Boards” is the headline of a Wall Street Journal op-ed:

Set aside Mr. Huang’s personal conduct. The case lays bare an Achilles’ heel that Beijing often exploits: the limited perspective of corporate boards. …

Yet few directors of major American companies have experience assessing political risk and the nature of regimes like communist China’s. They don’t learn it at business school or law school. Many directors have never worked or lived in a hostile environment like China’s, where there is no rule of law, property rights, independent boards or expectation of privacy. If they think about geopolitical risk, it’s often through the lens of regulatory risk, such as compliance with the 1977 U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act….

The [Huang] episode should also serve as a wake-up call to every American company doing business in places like China, and to the directors in their boardroom, too.

Axios has a story on how the Nvidia fiasco affects our personal finances.

The Nvidia scandal fuels the anti-AI movement. Rikki Schlott writes that this “neo-Luddite” movement forgets the “wonders and life-changing improvements” AI has brought us. Andy Kessler examines the benefits AI brings to medicine in “Doctors Have a New Assistant” in The Wall Street Journal.

Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland made the rounds of Sunday shows to talk about his announced challenge to Senator Schumer to be Senate Majority Leader. An editorial in The Wall Street Journal suggests that Van Hollen isn’t likely to depose Schumer:

It’s best understood as a warning from the party’s ascendant left wing: Toe the line on our agenda, or you won’t have a career after 2028. …

All of this ignores that Mr. Schumer has already moved sharply to the left in recent years. 

Eli Lake of The Free Press takes the Van Hollen challenge more seriously and interprets it as showing that the Democratic Party is changing:

If  you want to know just how far left the Democrats have traveled since their triumph in the midterms just two weeks ago, pay close attention to what happens to Senator Chuck Schumer.

Democratic power in five of the six states that spend the most money on voucher programs means that school choice is under threat. In “First They Came for the Children,” a Wall Street editorial explains:

That didn’t take long. Fresh off their statehouse victories around the country, Democrats are promising to use their power to eviscerate school voucher and education scholarship programs….

Democrats oppose the program because it offers parents a choice other than a failing neighborhood public school. Sarah Eckhardt, a Democratic state senator who was elected comptroller, voted against the ESAs and will oversee the program. She has called for more accountability and transparency, which is union code for using regulation to strangle the program….

Some 1.5 million children participate in private-school choice programs nationwide. Roughly half are in states that elected Democratic governors and could be affected by moves to restrict the programs. It’s a shame that children could become collateral damage to the voter rebuke of President Trump.

Townhall’s irrepressible Kurt Schlichter says the battle for the GOP presidential nomination for 2028 is wide open—but it won’t be JD Vance. Meanwhile, David Catron of the American Spectator writes that Ron DeSantis has won his 2028 shot by offering “a lesson in conservative governance that Washington Republicans would do well to learn.” Sasha Stone hails “Rubio Rising.” And Big Marco himself warned at a Federalist Society gathering about the International Criminal Court and the “weaponization of international law.”

Remember how we were told that “our democracy” was under attack? Surprise, surprise! “Perhaps the Rumors of Democracy’s Demise Were Premature,” a New York Times headline now tells us. You already know what saved it. Bill Glahn of Powerline comments.

Nerds want to be beautiful, too. “Meet the Matchmakers Getting Anthropic Employees Laid” in The Free Press is this morning’s most heartwarming story:

Soon-to-be-rich AI staffers are getting hair transplants, paying women to teach them intimacy, and spending $500,000 on elite matchmakers.

Just be careful about gorgeous Chinese ladies who might be overly interested in what you do at work all day.

Brand New Swamp. The Thune Conundrum. Chips Down for Jensen Huang? Bessent Moved to Military Base. Ode to Harmeet. Houellebecq. More

Secretary of War Pete Hegseth won the first battle after the midterm shellacking of the GOP merely by not being impeached. Elsewhere, the shellacking continued: Scott Colom wrested a Mississippi Senate seat from Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith, becoming the first black senator elected from Mississippi since Reconstruction. Also here and here.

Since there are still several Republicans serving in Congress, they bravely decided to elect their leadership. I was going to say “new” leadership, but oh my goodness. Senate Majority Leader John Thune will become Minority Leader, while coatless Rep. Jim Jordan will be House Minority Leader, which puts him on the Speaker path. American Greatness noted Republican recycling efforts.

The Federalist was merciless: “Senate Republicans Double Down on John Thune’s Failed Leadership.” “John Thune Isn’t to Blame for the GOP Wipeout,” counters the Wall Street Journal’s Free Expression section:

Republicans took a drubbing in the midterms, and the search for a scapegoat continues. For some in the party’s activist class, a leading candidate is soon-to-be Senate Minority Leader John Thune. Agitators on the right call him out-of-touch and ineffectual. They say he’s why the GOP got trounced.

Those critics are wrong. The midterms weren’t Mr. Thune’s fault.

When the American people re-elected President Trump in 2024, they did so because they wanted the 2019 economy back, not because they particularly liked him. Two years into his second term, Americans haven’t gotten the 2019 economy they wanted, but they’ve gotten a lot of Mr. Trump. Costs are high, the Iran war remains unresolved and Mr. Trump remains committed as ever to total chaos, all the time.

On Nov. 3, the American people sent him a clear message: We’re tired of it. 

“A GOP House of Ideas, or Hacks” is the response of the cerebral ones who write Wall Street Journal editorials:

Republicans on Tuesday chose Ohio Rep. Jim Jordan to lead what’s left of their minority in the House, and there’s no doubt the former wrestler’s specialty is grappling with the opposition. But to dig the party out of its deep hole, he’ll have to rebuild his conference’s intellectual capital—on taxes, healthcare and much else….

Newt Gingrich’s minority built a reform agenda on spending, Congressional ethics and welfare reform. … The best the GOP could muster in 2025 was extending the same tax cuts while mucking up the code with Mr. Trump’s carve-outs for car loans or tips that did nothing for economic growth. Hapless Republicans are now musing about the need to raise taxes to rescue Social Security even without any reform.

“Trump Got a Few Things Right” writes James B. Meigs, but Karl Rove worries: “What if Trump Still Thinks He’s Winning?” Not that the Dems are home free. Rove writes:

Democrats will be in the majority in Congress, but they’re also in a pickle. They constantly shouted “affordability” during the campaign but didn’t give voters much of an idea of their solutions. They had slogans like “more money in the pocket,” but not much beyond that.

Will Democrats also recycle leadership and make Senator Chuck Schumer Majority Leader and Rep. Hakeem Jeffries Speaker of the House? MS Now frets that this might be the case:

It’s an old political adage: You can’t beat somebody with nobody.

At the moment, that’s the big problem for the handful of Democratic lawmakers on Capitol Hill — both new and incumbent — who are calling for new leaders in the House and Senate. It’s also a problem for the torrent of online commentators critical of the current Democratic leaders: Who, exactly, would replace them?

But what if there is someone? “The new darling of the Democratic left is … Chris Van Hollen?” is a Politico headline. AOC is shaking up her team again in anticipation of running for something bigger than House leadership. Reemergent sage George Will proposes that on January 3, Democrats will run into reality:

In November, Democrats did well with voters, but beginning on Jan. 3, reality gets a vote. Consider four subjects: climate change, campaign finance, Medicare-for-all and racial gerrymandering.

Meanwhile, beleaguered Nvidia CEO Jenson Huang may be forced to gear down. The Nvidia board reportedly is preparing to oust Huang after his sexual relationship with an alleged Chinese spy was revealed. Washington Post columnist David Ignatius writes that the Huang scandal was “hiding in plain sight.” China’s spy service bets on lust and arrogance, according to Ignatius:

Keith Riggin, a former CIA station chief in Beijing who later advised U.S. companies on the Chinese intelligence threat, says he gave American executives a simple warning about beautiful women who might approach them in Beijing: “You don’t get any better-looking when you go to a place like China.”

It appears that the Nvidia espionage scandal is making Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick look less handsome because of his handling of sales of chips to China. Axios reports that Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent confronted Lutnick over Nvidia concerns in the Situation Room. Learn more about sexy alleged Chinese spy Alice Huang, the 31-year-old short trader who called out Huang’s “China problem,” and an alleged previous Jenson Huang paramour. 

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who is leading the economic pressure campaign against Iran, has been moved to a military base because of Iran’s threats against his life. “Iran’s Assassins Are on the Loose” is the headline of a Wall Street Journal editorial:

The IRGC is still on the loose, its Quds Force working to attack Americans, Jews and Iranian dissidents around the world. That’s how Iran’s terrorist regime operates, and it won’t stop even if a smiling thug shakes Mr. Vance’s hand and again promises that Iran will let oil tankers through the Strait of Hormuz when it gets everything else it wants.

There were some encouraging results in the midterms. “Thankfully, Child Transgenderism Lost on Election Day” is the headline on a story at RCP. Roy Eappen writes:

This reality has been overlooked in virtually all the coverage of the Republican bloodbath in House, Senate, and gubernatorial races. It’s true that Democrats romped to victory across the board, including in many races where their chances looked slim as recently as a few weeks ago. It’s also true that the new crop of elected Democrats still broadly embraces the most extreme gender ideology, especially when it comes to children.

Yet in three blue and purple states, gender ideology was explicitly on the ballot, and voters sided with common sense and protecting children. This story deserves more attention because it shows that Democrats are out of touch with a large percentage of their own voters.

I somehow managed to overlook Corey DeAngelis’ excellent “Even Blue States Support Female Athletes,” which tells the same story, a few days ago.

Warning. “When Democrats Say ‘Medicare for All,’ They Mean Medicare for None.” Will champions of patient-centered health reform seize upon and explain this important point?

Poetry to Our Ears. “An ode to Harmeet Dhillon” in the Washington Examiner.

Making Book. French novelist Michel Houellebecq’s novel “Submission” is one of the great literary works of our day. It describes a France falling to Islam without so much as a whimper. Houellebecq is facing prison time for “insulting Islam.” Simon Heffer writes about “The war against Michel Houellebecq” at Unherd. Heffer writes:

The decision to charge Houellebecq has been criticized as a freedom of speech issue; and so, to an extent, it is. French law in that respect differs somewhat from English, but doubtless his lawyers will have hours of lucrative fun arguing over the difference between inciting people to do something unspeakable and simply warning that society is moving in a direction where something unspeakable is likely to happen. Nearly sixty years after Enoch Powell was in the same position over dire prophesies he made in his so-called ‘Rivers of Blood’ speech.

Into the Future. Ross Douthat of The Free Press writes that President Trump still has hard choices to make that will determine his legacy. And Barton Swaim questions whether incoming Democrats are a rational opposition in “Midterms Add Madness to Chaos.” Point to ponder:

Writing in these pages in 1985, Irving Kristol alluded to the political scientist Martin Diamond’s dictum that American democracy “is based on one key assumption: that the people are usually sensible, but rarely wise.” Readers can judge if the people acted either sensibly or wisely by licensing one form of chaos to restrain another, but that is what they did on Nov. 3.

Step Right Up for Impeachment Theater. Red (As in Red China … ) Flags in Nvidia Spy Scandal. Why the Delay in the Charlie Kirk Murder Trial? Social Workers for Revolution! More

What’s first on the to do list for the final session of the 119th Congress? Well, impeaching a Cabinet member, for Pete’s sake.

Or not for Pete’s sake. The Wall Street Journal reports that the House is “barreling” towards a vote on whether to impeach Secretary of War Pete Hegseth. The articles of impeachment were filed by outgoing Republican Rep. Thomas Massie, who was a constant thorn President Trump’s side:

“We’re not indicting [Hegseth] for being bad at his job,” Massie said at a press conference on Monday. “The argument here is that he’s broken laws and he’s violated the Constitution.”

Asked why he was seeking to impeach Hegseth and not the president himself, Massie said impeaching President Trump over war powers was “an impossible hurdle” and Hegseth was “the better target.”

An editorial in the Wall Street Journal addresses what will undoubtedly be “The Hegseth Impeachment Spectacle:”

So much for working together. After their victory last week, House Democrats have decided their first act of statesmanship will be to vote to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. This is a self-defeating exercise if you want a new Defense chief or an early end to the Iran war.

“I’m a hard yes on the Hegseth resolution,” Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries said over the weekend. …

Mr. Jeffries may think this is a free vote he can give his left-wingers before Democrats take control in January. But voters will see through this and notice that Democrats are more preoccupied with shooting at Mr. Hegseth than bringing the war in Iran to a victorious end.

Hegseth is expected to hold a press conference this morning.

Nvidia CEO Jenson Huang’s relationship with suspected Chinese spy Alice Huang has “spiraled into a national security nightmare.” A Wall Street editorial calls the emerging scandal a “Chinese honeypot lesson” for Nvidia. Nvidia’s “celebrity CEO” apparently missed several glaring red (as in Red China) flags:

Ms. Huang previously worked at a Chinese state-run media company and founded Megaspeed in 2023. Megaspeed was spun off by Chinese video game maker, 7Road Holdings, soon after the Biden team imposed restrictions on AI chip sales to China. Coincidence, comrade? Megaspeed was then sold to a Singapore-based shell company in November 2023.

Soon afterward, Nvidia designated Megaspeed a “Cloud Partner,” which gave it priority access to advanced chips. Press reports say Megaspeed has bought billions of dollars of Nvidia chips, which are hosted in data centers in the Asia-Pacific outside of China.

Mr. Huang has apologized to his family and shareholders. Fox Digital’s Rebecca Grant says he also owes an apology to the United States:

A Chinese assault on Nvidia is scary for Americans because Nvidia holds as much as an 80% market share of the world’s most advanced data center AI chips. Nvidia is the “go-to choice for all the biggest AI software developers,” as explained by Yahoo Finance.

The carelessness is unfathomable. Can you imagine if the CEO of a top U.S. defense company was caught in a close relationship with a suspected Chinese operative? One has to wonder: Does Huang not realize that Nvidia has made him a major national security player and, therefore, a target for espionage?

The New York Post reports “exclusive details” of Huang’s lobbying his “very good friend” President Trump, which included a $25 million contribution to the President’s ballroom project. President Trump said that the FBI is looking into Huang but expressed confidence that nothing criminal would be found.

Meet the woman at the center of the Huang-Huang scandal.

Nobody can accuse the Judge slated to preside over the Charlie Kirk murder trial of a rush towards judgement. Judge Tony Graff has set the trial to begin in summer of 2028. Notice that’s not even next year. Graf set aside 105 trial days—about five months for the trial. Kirk’s family is “disappointed.”

Why the delay? I don’t get it. Maybe Bill Glahn of Powerline does: 

On that schedule, the trial will extend through the 2028 election, giving Democrats opportunities to motivate their base by celebrating Kirk’s assassination on the campaign trail.

The other thing I don’t get is why certain people are gleefully obsessed with the murder of a young man whose “sin” was debate. Good on Piers Morgan and Charlamange tha God for slamming Dave Chappelle’s unfunny joke about Kirk’s murder. Erika Kirk—can you imagine how this malice makes her feel?—called the ‘joke’ “disgusting.”

Speaking hate, here’s another good question, posed by Victor Davis Hanson: Why Do They Despise Elon Musk?

In addition to considering the impeachment of Secretary Hegseth, both parties face choosing their new leaders. Both Senate Majority Leader John Thune and Minority Leader Chuck Schumer face possible headwinds. Senators Josh Hawley and Rick Scott have said they will not vote for Senator Thune after the midterm wipeout of the GOP. Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, who hopes to be Speaker, ‘faces uncertainty from incoming Democrats.” Republicans will choose between Steve Scalise and Jim Jordan for Minority Leader. Enquiring Minds Want to Know: If elected, will Mr. Jordan finally purchase a coat jacket?

Are you comforted by the thought that social workers are can be dispatched to deal with crises? In,” “Social Work Isn’t Helping Anyone” Pamala Garfield-Jaeger, who trained as a social worker at NYU, writes that social workers are now often trained to bring about social change. She highlights a conference hosted by the Council on Social Work Education that she attended:

The conference was littered with my profession’s power brokers, the deans and educators who run the country’s 600-plus accredited social work schools. And as far as I could tell, I was the only attendee who wasn’t a Marxist intent on destroying Western civilization.

The advertised theme was “rooted in resilience.” After I attended more than a dozen main-stage presentations and breakout sessions, it became obvious that the real message was “overthrow the system.” Individual choices are inconsequential, personal agency doesn’t exist and people are victims of an unjust and illegitimate order that must be destroyed through the forces of politics.

According to those at the conference, the way to foster a better “system” is through the destruction of capitalism and “decolonization.” The latter was the second most popular buzzword I heard at the conference, after “racism.” One professor got weepy, saying she needed to “decenter myself as a white person.” When a speaker at the awards ceremony said the white percentage of the population was dropping, he got massive applause.

Thinking Ahead. In “America’s Future Is in the Classroom,” John J. Miller argues that that winning the next generation is even more important than winning the next election:

Socialists “always run out of other people’s money,” warned Margaret Thatcher. Yet they never seem to run out of other people’s children. That’s why they and their allies continue to enjoy political success, as they did in the Nov. 3 midterm elections.

Winning the next election always matters, but even more important is winning the next generation. Conservatives and other friends of free enterprise must play a long game as they seek to recover from the rout of 2026. Their strategy should include the liberation of America’s schools from state control.

“If we fail to teach our students about historical—and ongoing—oppression and violence under the world’s communist and socialist regimes, we are leaving them vulnerable to the same failed ideas repackaged for the digital age by slick demagogues, slogans, and social media influencers,” wrote Education Secretary Linda McMahon in a letter that called for observing the National Day for the Victims of Communism on Nov. 7.

Presented with facts, students will recoil as they learn about the rotten legacy of the Soviet Union’s gulags and Cambodia’s killing fields as well as China’s lethal campaigns of collectivization and the massacre at Tiananmen Square. “The hammer and sickle should be as known and detested as the swastika,” said Elizabeth Spalding, chairman of the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation, which offers curriculum materials on the crimes of communism, the freedom movements that have resisted tyranny and more.

School choice, which the majority in the next Congress will try to squelch, is the solution, according to Miller.

Trump WAS on the Ballot. In Wake of Losses, J.D. Mighty Quick to Pat Himself on the Back. El-Sayed: Sore Winner. Dem Victories Imperil AI Boom. Don’t Stop Thinking about Tomorrow. More

President Trump got his wish—voters pretended he was on the ballot. Karl Rove writes in his political column this morning:

Both parties agreed on this tumultuous midterm election’s essential point. President Trump wanted voters to “pretend I’m on the ballot.” With his approval at 38%, Democrats happily agreed.

The results were catastrophic for Republicans. They lost almost everywhere, including places where defeat was once unimaginable.

This midterm will be remembered decades from now. Republican losses were massive and consequential….

This midterm defeat, one of the worst in a half-century, leaves the Trump presidency crippled. There’s no chance of confirming a conservative Supreme Court justice in the next two years, and maybe the next six. Republicans who have been afraid to break with the president will now do so, if only for self-preservation. The president will dodge responsibility and blame others. He’s already proclaimed on X, “I wasn’t on the Ballot and if I was, we would have won IN A LANDSLIDE.” Not true.

Mr. Trump can’t escape blame so easily. He and his policies and candidate choices burned the Republican Party to the ground.

Miranda Devine, who has generally been more sympathetic to President Trump than the Bush-associated Rove, writes that President Trump “can’t pretend the electoral rout wasn’t a referendum on him and his smashmouth politics that needlessly alienates people.” Regrettably, so many of the President’s pet peeves are not central to the worries of the voters—think Reflectint Pool lining—as Pete Laffin makes clear in “The Bulls*** Golden Age Is Over.”

Possibly the most fascinating response to the GOP’s historic drubbing comes from Vice President J.D. Vance. The Wall Street Journal addresses this in “JD Vance’s Theory of Election Defeat.” I think “doesn’t mince words” is how we describe something this brutal:

The Vice President didn’t wait to pat himself on the back and assign blame elsewhere for the GOP’s electoral wipeout. Amid the rubble on the morning after the election, JD Vance posted a mini-essay on X.com to pin the defeat entirely on the war in Iran and suggest that ending it is a political necessity. By doing so in public, Mr. Vance signals desperation to Iran’s regime, undermining his boss at a critical moment in the war.

The selective blame is no accident. While the Vice President has become a true believer on tariffs and hard-line immigration restriction, unidentified leakers to the press throughout the Iran war have suggested he opposed it. When Mr. Vance now writes, “To the people who are pi**** off and want to say, ‘I told you so’: you’re right, you did tell us so,” he’s thinking of himself….

Nothing on Mr. Vance’s list of ways to win back Trump 2024 voters gives evidence of any self-reflection, least of all “4) Change our relationship to Israel.” That’s the message of the Jews-on-the-mind podcast ecosystem promoted by Mr. Vance and led by his friend and ally Tucker Carlson. The exit poll shows only 4% of voters rank foreign-policy issues first.

It’s highly unusual for a Vice President to break with a President in such a very public way. “Tehran Us Apart” is the New York Post front-page headline for the Veep’s putting the blame for the shellacking of his party on the Iran war.

Because of the thoroughness of the blue sweep, it would have been difficult for any Republican to win in Texas. Even popular Senator John Cornyn, defeated in the primary by the scandal-prone Trump pick, likely would have lost. But give the guy his say (“Republicans Forgot How to Win Elections“). Cornyn writes:

This year, losing candidates like Ken Paxton and Mike Collins shrank the tent, obsessing over “RINOs” and political theater. In Texas, statewide candidate Bo French poisoned the well even further with blatant bigotry against Indian-Americans, anathema to the party of Lincoln and Reagan. When nominees show contempt for voters and request a smaller Republican Party, voters oblige them.

The second forgotten lesson was even simpler: Be likeable. We are no longer in 2010, when articulate, appealing conservatives like Marco Rubio and Pat Toomey challenged “establishment” candidates over real policy differences. Today, it is fringe challengers who play down voting records and policy in favor of performative politics. A strange reverse personality test has taken root. If a candidate talks like an affable, reasonable person, he must be a sellout.

Nevertheless, on the likeability front, victorious Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed probably doesn’t score that high. In “El-Sayed Is Your Classic Sore Winner,” Matthew Hennessey writes:

Victorious Michigan Democrat Abdulrahman Mohamed El-Sayed went all the way in the wrong direction, mocking his opponent, former Rep. Mike Rogers, for losing. “Mike, enjoy your retirement,” smirked Mr. El-Sayed, who may be one of the ostentatiously jerkiest guys ever to win high office.

And before you come at me for using the senator-elect’s full name, that’s how he introduced himself to the crowd on election night. He even put a thick dollop of Arabic accent on top as if he wants everybody to say it that way. Let the man be called what he wants to be called….

If, one day, civilization does go down, we won’t know which personal failure, which political expediency, which overlooked courtesy or which slight deception tipped the balance. We’ll simply know we had something precious once, and lost it.

Spiked on Line’s Brendan O’Neill contends that Michigan’s Senate race was identity politics at its deadliest.

There have been several reports comparing the blue tsunami we experienced Tuesday with the GOP wipeout after Watergate. The Democrats coming to Washington this time, however, are much more to the left than then. The U.K. Telegraph heralds five Democrats to watch—all progressives. Representative-elect Darializa Avila Chevalier of New York, best known for extreme statements and wiping her hands on the American flag, prepares to come to Washington at a party in a Harlem tavern:

There was little ambiguity about what the assembled crowd wanted. They wanted a transformed America: one without ICE, billionaires, private health insurance, or tuition bills. They wanted to defeat the establishment, and they believed they were well on their way.

How they will accomplish these goals is anyone’s guess. But on Tuesday night in Harlem, at least, the revolution was in high spirits.

One of the biggest potential losers in Tuesday’s elections was America’s AI boom. But there were ballot measures that passed that should gladden the hearts of the sensible. California’s millionaire’s tax failed. Apparently, even California has reservations about exiling job-creating, tax-paying billionaires. This, this, and this were written before the vote but will explain the tax.

Common sense ballot measures banning men who identify as “trans” women from women’s sports were approved in four states: Nebraska, Arizona, Washington, and Colorado.  

I want to end this morning by looking to the future. Alex Castellanos, the Republican media consultant, was on Fox’s Special Report last night. Here is part of what he said (as reported by Real Clear Politics):


We don’t have a Republican Party right now. That space was occupied by Donald Trump. Now, I think we should have one. Every nation should. And the debate now is going to be what the Republican Party stands for. Can we build on Donald Trump’s substantial accomplishments and say, here’s where we go next?

There will be no different Donald Trump tomorrow than there was yesterday. So if we’re going to create a new Republican Party, the next Republican Party is going to be up to candidates like DeSantis, Rubio, and others.

Wall Street Journal columnist Holman Jenkins also looks to the future:

I’ve been writing “Trump throws it all away—again” columns practically since the Pete Hegseth Signal chat bumble in March 2025.

With luck, this will have been our last Trump-vs.-Trump election. That means the last in which Democrats could ignore the chaos and policy insanity in their own camp because they had Donald Trump to run against….

News for these folks: The country is going to be around long after Mr. Trump is gone. His policy excursions aren’t going to be the last word on anything. America would have benefited a lot more if Mr. Trump could have left in 2029 with an above-water approval rating, communicating to the political class a simple verdict: The public doesn’t want the new socialism or racist identity politics. It wants something resembling the traditional American peace, prosperity and national strength that Mr. Trump sought to embody.

Cheer up.

Historic GOP Wipeout. Republican Strongholds Fall. Guess Who Doesn’t Have to Pretend to Like Barbecue Anymore? Blame Heaped on Trump. Will Dems Misinterpret Win? More

Yesterday we lived in one world. Today we live in a very different one. Here are some descriptions of what happened:

Massacre. Armageddon. Historic Defeat for Trump, Republicans. And my personal favorite: “From the river to the sea. Blue tsunami reckoning.“

Last night was a wholesale Democratic rout of the GOP. “Trump told voters, ‘Pretend I’m on the ballot.’ They did” is the headline on a Washington Post report that calls the Democrats’ sweep of both houses of Congress “by some measures the worst since the post-Watergate election of 1974.”

The latest tally, which might be subject to change, is devastating for Republicans. Democrats will have 54 Senate seats to the GOP’s 42. They will have 223 House seats compared to the Republicans’ 131. The Squad is receiving new members, who might be further to the left. Fox Digital introduces the new DSA members coming to Congress.

Republican strongholds went to the Democrats. James Talarico defeated Texas AG Ken Paxton to become the first U.S. Senator from Texas since 1988. Mississippi Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith lost to Democrat challenger Scott Colom, but at least this one was close. Senator Roger Marshall lost Kansas to first-time candidate Adam Hamilton; Kansas hasn’t elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1932. South Carolina Senator Darline Graham lost her brother’s, the late Senator Lindsey Graham, seat to Democrat Amy Adams.

Maine Senator Susan Collins isn’t in a red state, but she’s always managed to eke out a win. Last night her luck ran out:

Democrat Troy Jackson defeated longtime Sen. Susan Collins Tuesday in Maine’s midterm Senate election, ending the incumbent’s nearly 30-year-long run in the upper chamber.

Jackson garnered 52.7% of the vote, compared to Collins’ 47.2%, with about two-thirds of the ballots tallied.

It’s a remarkable turnaround for Jackson, the third-place finisher in the Maine Democratic primary for governor, who was swapped in at the last minute after the campaign imploded for the original Senate nominee, Graham Platner.

Collins, 73, will leave Congress as the longest-serving female Republican senator in history. 

The most watched race was Michigan’s Senate race. Despite allegations of Muslim Brotherhood connections, progressive Abdul El-Sayed defeated Mike Rogers by a handsome margin. El-Sayed, who will be the Senate’s first Muslim member, used Arabic phrases to mock President Trump in his acceptance speech. “I’ve answered all the questions that I care to answer,” El-Sayed, famously argumentative with reporters, said.

Minnesota Senate candidate Michelle Tafoya’s candidacy excited many Republicans, but she nevertheless lost to Lieutenant Governor Peggy Flanagan, whom the Free Beacon describes as Governor Tim Walz’s “Wingwoman.” In addition to the GOP’s congressional losses, Texas Governor Greg Abbot lost his job. The Dems also flipped Ohio’s governorship, as Vivek Ramasamy went down in defeat.

“The Trump Reckoning Arrives,” a merciless Wall Street Journal editorial proclaims. The editors write that President Trump’s “2024 coalition rebukes his second-term priorities and performance.” They write:

Republicans may console themselves that midterm defeats in second presidential terms are common. But this was more than a normal defeat. …

Mr. Trump is directly responsible for at least three Senate defeats: Mr. Paxton when he could have endorsed Mr. Cornyn instead; North Carolina, where he drove Sen. Thom Tillis from running for re-election; and Darline Graham, whom he pressed to run to replace her late brother, Lindsey Graham, despite her lack of political experience or policy knowledge.

More broadly, the President’s erratic and self-indulgent second-term governance has alienated much of the coalition he assembled in 2024. He won a second term on the promise to repeat the economic success of his first. But this time he insisted on imposing universal tariffs, often willy-nilly, that have raised prices for many goods and been especially damaging in Iowa, Kansas and the Farm Belt. His senseless trade war with Canada hurt Republicans in Michigan, Maine, even Texas. …

Voters also rebelled against Mr. Trump’s seeming preoccupation with his pet personal causes—the ballroom, the arch—and how he and his family have grown richer during the second term. No less than 88% of voters mentioned “corruption” as their top concern in an October Fox News poll, a higher percentage than the 85% who said inflation.

Democrats linked costs and corruption in their ads to damaging effect. Even if the link isn’t fair or true, it played to the frustration of voters that the President’s family is doing well while they are not. The charge of corruption is likely to haunt Mr. Trump across the next two years, as Democrats in Congress investigate the deals and details.

The Federalist’s John Daniel Davidson blames President Trump for what he calls the nationwide collapse of the Republican Party.  Davidson specifically blames the Iran war, which Davidson sees as “a historic betrayal.”

New York Post columnist Michael Goodwin writes that how President Trump reacts to this “shellacking will determine his place in history.” Goodwin writes:

Still, tomorrow begins a new challenge for Trump and his beaten-down White House. It would certainly help if he ate some crow in public and took full responsibility for the outcome.

He could do worse than quote the Bob Dylan lyrics, “I threw it all away.”

Not that he will because he specializes in excess, and deems it a badge of manly pride to thumb his nose at tradition.

But even he has to signal to the American public that he still intends to serve their interest.

Most brutal: Matthew Hennesey’s “Revenge of the Nerds,” which contains the breathtaking line “Live by the ego maniac, die by the ego maniac.” President Trump has said that he will accept the results. Christopher Rufo writes that “reprisals are coming” because now that the midterms are over, “Democrats will seek revenge.” MS NOW is even more blunt: “‘Lawyer up’: A new Democratic majority prepares for a slate of Trump investigations.”

There’s no denying that the Democrats had a historic win last night. What will they do with it? “Will Democrats Misread Their Victory?” a Wall Street Journal editorial demands:

The first essential lesson is that voters are handing Democrats power because they wanted to rebuke President Trump. They think he failed to deliver on his promise to lower prices, and they don’t like his excesses on the rule of law, tariffs, mass deportation, and crony cashing in.

The political danger is that Democrats won’t be able to control themselves. They didn’t in Mr. Trump’s first term, and it cost them politically. One key test will be whether they can resist the calls to impeach him again. Nancy Pelosi didn’t, and her efforts merely solidified the President’s Republican support. Unless Democrats uncover something serious enough to get Republican Senators to convict after a House impeachment, they would be wise to settle for oversight and informing the voters.

Legislatively the next two years will feature the frustrations of divided government. Unfortunately for the country, given the $40 trillion debt and last year’s $2 trillion deficit, Congress typically papers over disagreements by spending even more.

Did Democrats learn a lesson from Mr. Biden’s spending binge, which fueled the inflation that cost him re-election? As workers worry about energy prices, will the party go straight back to climate mandates and subsidies for expensive electric cars?

Up All Nacht. Meanwhile, Jason Riley writes that with the results of the midterm, President Trump is a lame duck and “his long good-bye” begins. But Riley’s most chilling observation is not about President Trump:

If progressive candidates like Mr. El-Sayed are successful Tuesday, it’s an indication that Jew-hatred plays not only in liberal precincts like Zohran Mamdani’s New York but also in the swing states of the Midwest. If that’s the case, expect to see more Abdul El-Sayeds running for office. That might keep some Democrats up at night.

Slated for Reeducation Camp. The Babylon Bee is spot on about what led to this sea change in American politics: “Idiot King Forgets to Cancel Election“:

Washington, D.C. –Boy has King Trump got egg on his face this time. Seeing all of the people going to vote, he realized he forgot to cancel the election. What an idiot!

“Kings aren’t supposed to have elections. Doesn’t he know that? What a dummy,” said one peasant. “Well, time to vote against his interests, because he’s so dumb.”

“Why am I so stupid? Don’t answer that!” said King Trump.

What Will We Know Late Tonight? Five Words That Will Determine the Outcome. Veteran Scribe: We Need a Smaller Tent. Oh, And We’re Bombing Iran. Tucker Will Be Upset. More

Will we know which party will control Congress by bedtime?

Here’s the Washington Post breakdown on poll closings, but it’s still not too late for predictions.

 “A terrible night awaits the GOP, and even that might be an understatement,” predicts Washington Post columnist Henry Olsen. Olsen writes:

You don’t have to be a prophet to see what’s coming. No serious analyst thinks Republicans will have a good night as midterm returns roll in. The open question is whether it will be merely bad, terrible or something akin to being eaten by a Cyclops.

In this column, the 12th version of my biennial election prediction memo, I’m taking the middle course: I foresee a terrible night for the GOP, with losses in the House of 20 seats and a Democratic takeover of the Senate. Team Red will also lose many governorships and state legislative chambers as the public expresses, up and down the ballot, its significant dismay at the course of Trump’s presidency.

Communications strategist Lee Carter is an extremely serious political analyst—but she doesn’t hazard a prediction; instead, Carter focuses on “the five words that explain this election“: “Affordability. Socialism. Corruption. Trump. Turnout.” The categories aren’t cut and dried. Every single one of them cuts both ways. Turnout, for example:

A wave of Democratic enthusiasm in safely blue districts won’t change control of Congress. A smaller Republican surge in a handful of competitive races could.

And a relatively modest number of independents deciding to stay home or to show up could rewrite the headlines.

The polls can tell us where voters stand.

Tuesday will tell us which voters stand up.

The Dems have a “weekend from Hell” (including Haley Stevens’ endorsement of Republican Mike Rogers over Abdul El-Sayed and continued fallout from the two Dans in Alaska), but James Antle of the Examiner asks if it will matter. Axios worries that, if the Dems do win big tonight, they will reinterpret the message:

Democrats are poised to romp in today’s election — easily winning the House and, according to most forecasts, flipping the Senate too. Yet the party itself is less popular than the IRS. Even the GOP has a better brand. …

But polls across the board still show a lesser-of-two-evils election — or as one Republican tied to President Trump’s political operation described it, a contest of which party voters hate more. Voters are more eager to disempower Trump than to empower Democrats.

If the Democrats were to take both Houses of Congress, it would further empower the already surging progressive wing of the party. In a Free Press story headlined “The Democratic Tent Is Too Big,” veteran reporter Joe Klein states his reservations: “I would like both houses of Congress to gain Democratic majorities, but not at the cost of empowering extremists who don’t like Israel or, more to the point, Jews.” 

A New York Post story by Victor Nava shows how the DSA’s midterm socialist takeover could unfold on Election Night. Nava provides a candidate-by-candidate look at what might happen. We should stress here that nobody knows for certain what will happen overall tonight. Alaskans are going to the polls with the controversy over the two Dans unresolved.

“When Does a Dirty Trick Become a Crime?” lawyer George J. Terwillinger III asks regarding the Alaska mess. Terwilliger makes a case for investigating the case, but the question is complicated:

“Politics ain’t beanbag,” as Finley Peter Dunne’s fictional Chicago saloonkeeper, Mr. Dooley, famously observed. But throughout American history, political combat has remained subject to legal limits. The boundary between shady and illegal activity isn’t always clear, but there is a zone that, when entered, can expose political operations and operatives to accusations of criminal conduct in their political affairs….

One way the dirty trick can easily become a criminal matter is through misconduct by the participants in the course of investigation of a dirty trick. Watergate is the most prominent example. The dirty trick was itself a crime—a burglary seeking kompromat of the opposition party by bugging its headquarters. The men who carried it out were charged with burglary, wiretapping and conspiracy. But it was the attempts by its intended beneficiaries, including President Richard Nixon, to conceal the crime and hinder the investigation for which several appointees, aides and operatives went to prison and Nixon resigned rather than face impeachment. Thus did that dirty trick get turned on its head, producing the adage “The coverup is worse than the crime.”

In the Alaska matter, an intentional effort to confuse voters to harm Sen. Sullivan’s re-election surely falls under the rubric of dirty tricks, which Merriam-Webster defines as “underhanded stratagems for obtaining secret information about or sabotaging an enemy or for discrediting an opponent (as in politics).” But is it a crime—or could it become one by way of conduct during an investigation?

Meanwhile, Examiner Chief Political Correspondent Byron York takes a look at the “acrimony” and “funky polls” in the Michigan Senate race. Democrat Haley Stevens, who endorsed Republican Mike Rogers over Abdul El-Sayed, was the wild card in Michigan. Ed Morrissey of Hot Air took note of the vicious reaction from the “party of women” to Ms. Haley’s decision, especially James Carville’s reference to her as a “used condom.”

Speaking of foul language, Meghan Gurdon writes that, “Politics Needs a Swear Jar.” That’s definitely got my vote.

Turning Point? With this election, it can be argued that America’s two political parties are in for the first reshaping of the landscape since Andrew Jackson and Martin Van Buren invented Democrats. Election Day itself, Barton Swain points out, one of our great traditions, is dying:

For about 100 years, from the early 20th century to the early 21st, Americans voted almost wholly together. The custom offered a splendid example of unity in division. In the early republic and in various ways through the 19th century, laws accommodated early votes for servicemen stationed abroad and citizens living in remote locales. Modern early voting offers something different: convenience.

Another reason to vote on Election Day, not before: You can learn a lot about a candidate in the weeks before an election….  Alaskans would go to the polls with more intelligence than 41,000 of them had in the first week of early voting. Not for the first time, patience receives its reward.

Multitasking. The U.S. struck Iran’s Qeshm Island yesterday. Let’s hope this doesn’t set off Tucker Carlson. Carlson is insisting that President Trump is on the verge of going nuclear (as in weapons). Relax. Tucker’s been wrong before.

You Should Make a Silk Purse Out of That. The American Psychological Association is having an accreditation crisis. Joseph Figliolia suggests in City Journal that the nation’s largest professional organization for psychologists should view this as an opportunity:

Critics charged the APA with politicizing its programs, including the embrace of “critical” psychotherapies that make dubious assumptions about “gender identity” and label Jews colonial oppressors. The APA’s commitment to social-justice ideology undermines its program quality and nondiscrimination standards, commenters noted, particularly in its failure to address complaints of anti-Semitism. …

How can the APA turn its ship around? Some basic reforms include introducing a scientific integrity standard, definitions for what constitutes “unsettled” scientific areas, a revised “non-discrimination” standard, and clearer protocols for navigating program complaints.

First, the APA should recommit itself to open scientific inquiry on controversial issues like gender medicine. That would mean adding “scientific integrity” to its enumerated professional values for accredited programs. Doing so would help ensure that APA-accredited programs create environments where faculty and students can teach and research competing scientific viewpoints in good faith….

In an era defined by public distrust in institutions, the APA has a rare opportunity to stand up for scientific integrity, evidence-based practice, and equal access. For the sake of patients and trainees, let’s hope that it seizes it.

The men in women’s sports issue reared its head in Maine, where two high school girls yesterday spoke out about competing against male athletes who identify as “trans” women:

“Many girls and women are discovering the crushing disappointment that comes from being beaten in their own sports by males who should have never been allowed to compete in the first place,” Wilson said.

Alliance Defending Freedom has taken their case.

See you tomorrow. The Force be with you.